7/09/2010

Why Should We Assess Library Reference Services?

First, the assessment of reference services help libraries substantiate the need for certain resources and services, particularly when funding is low and there is a demand for electronic resources. To forestall budget cuts (or perhaps request budget expansion), a reference department needs to be able to show its ROI (Return On Investment).

And sometimes assessment is required. The U.S. Government Performance and Results Act requires federal agencies to have quantifiable and measurable performance goals. This has an impact on other agencies that seek federal grants.


Here are a couple articles that might be of interest:
  • Holt, G., & Elliot, D. (2003, Winter). "Measuring outcomes: applying cost-benefit analysis to middle-sized and smaller public libraries." Library Trends 51(3), 424-440.
    • In this article, Holt & Elliot argue for cost-benefit analysis (ROI, basically) in smaller public libraries, where such methods have traditionally been absent. They also describe how the process works in that environment.
  • Buschman, J. (2004, August). Staying Public: the real crisis in librarianship. American Libraries, 35(7), 40-42.
    • Buschman takes a provocative stance. Although he does not question library reference assessment directly, he explores the problems with porting private sector philosophies (such as the desire to quantify through ROI) into the public sector. Buschman argues, "We have unthinkingly imported business models on a massive scale into public enterprises" (p. 40-41).
In any case, assessment can still be useful. Even if funding and ROI are left out of the equation, a reference department should always be looking for way to provide the best services possible to its patrons.

No comments:

Post a Comment